Nothing tests a flight’s on-time record quite like the week before Christmas. Between winter storms, packed terminals, and every airline running at max capacity, the holidays are prime season for flight delays and travel mishaps, and whether that happens to you often depends on which airline’s ticket you hold.
The Travel Bulletin team dug into 5 years of Department of Transportation data covering the 2021 to 2025 holiday travel seasons to find out which airlines actually deliver on time, and which ones are more likely to leave you stranded at the gate.
In this article
The Shortcut
Of the 4.17 million flights over the last five holiday seasons, 19.77% were delayed, and 1.46% were canceled, meaning more than one in five flights ran into trouble.
Delta Air Lines posted the lowest delay rate of any airline (15.3%) over that stretch, while American and United tied for the lowest cancellation rate at 0.94%.
JetBlue delayed the highest share of flights (27.93%), with delays averaging 71.6 minutes. Southwest Airlines had the shortest delays, averaging 51.3 minutes.
Major airlines handled more than 382.8 million bags from 2021 to 2025, and nearly 2.2 million were lost or damaged, about one mishandled bag for every two flights.
What We Looked At
We focused on the 10 major U.S. mainline passenger airlines, using five years of flight data and baggage data from the Department of Transportation. We scored each airline on four factors related to on-time performance and baggage handling to identify the best and worst at keeping your holiday trip on schedule.
Percentage of flights delayed: The share of each airline’s November and December flights from 2021 to 2025 that arrived 15 minutes or more behind schedule.
Percentage of flights canceled: The share of each airline’s holiday flights that were canceled outright over that same five-year span.
Average delay length: The average number of minutes a flight arrived after its scheduled time, calculated only across flights that were actually delayed.
Percentage of bags mishandled: The share of checked bags reported lost, damaged, delayed, or pilfered during the holidays from 2021 to 2025.
Each airline received a “Holiday Travel Reliability Score” out of 50. Higher scores mean a more reliable holiday trip.
The Best Airlines for Holiday Travel
The holidays are one of the busiest times of the year for travel, increasing passenger traffic at U.S. airports. In some parts of the country, the holidays also bring wintery weather, which can disrupt airline schedules. When it comes to handling the holiday hiccups these factors bring, some airlines are better than others.

Based on government data for the last five years’ worth of holiday travel, Delta Air Lines leads the way, earning a holiday travel reliability score of 34.3. Only 15.3% of Delta’s holiday flights ran late, the lowest rate of any airline and more than four full percentage points below the overall industry average of 19.77%. Delta also canceled only 1% of flights and kept its mishandled bag rate below 0.5%, both rates below the overall industry average.
In terms of overall reliability, Hawaiian Airlines came second (33), helped by some of the shortest delays of any airline (52.7 minutes on average) and a low mishandled bag rate of 0.48%. Southwest placed third (28.1) thanks in part to the shortest average delay length of any airline, 51.3 minutes.
At the bottom, JetBlue scored 14.9 for holiday reliability, the lowest of any airline. 27.93% of JetBlue’s flights during the last five holiday seasons were delayed, the highest delay rate of any carrier. Two other airlines, Allegiant (26.71%) and Frontier (25.94%), had more than a quarter of their flights delayed. Frontier shares another similarity with JetBlue: their average holiday flight delay length exceeds 70 minutes. It should come as no surprise, then, that Frontier has the second-worst holiday reliability score (16.4).
Airlines With the Most Flight Delays and Cancellations
A delayed or canceled flight can start the traditionally cheery holiday season off on a sour note.

Cancellations are rare, but they’re the worst-case scenario when you have somewhere to be. Across five holiday seasons, airlines canceled 60,705 flights, or 1.46% of the schedule.
American and United had the lowest cancellation rates at 0.94% each, with Delta close behind at 1%. Alaska (2.26%) and Southwest (2.11%) canceled holiday flights at the highest rates. However, Southwest’s number comes with an asterisk. In December 2022 alone, the airline canceled 17,000 flights because of a scheduling and operational crisis initially caused by bad weather. That alone accounts for more than 70% of all its holiday cancellations over the last 5 years. In the other four holiday seasons, Southwest canceled just 0.66% of its flights.
Delays are far more common than cancellations, and they’re where the airlines differ most. JetBlue ran late on 27.93% of holiday flights, the most of any airline, followed by Allegiant (26.71%) and Frontier (25.94%). On the other end of the spectrum, just 15.3% of Delta’s holiday flights were delayed, and two other airlines, United (18.18%) and Southwest (19.5%), also kept delay rates under 20%.
Airlines With The Longest Holiday Flight Delays
Not all delays are created equal. Landing 20 minutes behind schedule is a minor annoyance, while being an hour or more late can be a major headache… especially when you’re trying to make it to grandma's.

The longest average delays belong to Allegiant (76 minutes), American (76 minutes), and Frontier (75 minutes). American is an outlier: the airline rarely cancels a holiday flight (just 0.94% of flights canceled), but when it runs late, it runs very late. If you’re booking a tight connection on American this holiday season, give yourself extra layover time.
Three airlines have average delay times that are well below the industry average of 65 minutes. Southwest leads with the lowest average delay time at 51 minutes, followed closely by Hawaiian Airlines and Alaska Airlines at 53 minutes each.
Mishandled Luggage During The Holiday Season
Lost or damaged luggage is never a good thing, but it can be especially devastating during the holiday season when many are traveling with gifts.

During the 2021 to 2025 holiday seasons, major U.S. airlines checked 382.8 million bags in total and mishandled nearly 2.2 million of them, a rate of 0.57%.
Allegiant stood out positively, mishandling just 0.16% of bags, or about one in 640. That is the lowest rate of any airline by a wide margin. This may be due in large part to the airline’s operational structure: as a budget carrier that charges passengers for every bag they bring, Allegiant encourages customers to pack light, reducing the amount of luggage it has for handle.
American had the highest rate of mishandled baggage at 0.75%, about one in 134, followed by Alaska (0.69%) and United (0.65%). Those three airlines frequently move travelers through major connecting hubs, and each transfer creates another chance for a bag to miss its flight. Comparatively, Allegiant mostly flies nonstop, point-to-point routes, so most of its checked bags never change planes, another factor keeping its mishandled bag rates lower.
Full Holiday Travel Data
Cancellations and Delays, November and December 2021 to 2025
Mishandled Luggage, November and December 2021 to 2025
Ways to Protect Your Holiday Travel Plans
Know what you’re owed if a delay happens. Airlines have different rules for compensation, and it’s worth knowing what you’re entitled to before your flight gets rebooked.
Consider travel insurance before you book. Your travel insurance policy can cover more than a missed flight. Review what’s actually covered so you’re not surprised when you need it most.
Keep tabs on your bags. Holiday travel means more checked luggage and more chances for it to go missing. A luggage tracker can give you peace of mind by pinpointing where your suitcase is, whether it makes it onto your flight.
Speed through security when it’s busiest. With holiday crowds packing terminals, TSA PreCheck’s touchless ID can shave real time off your wait.
Methodology
Travel Bulletin collected data published by the U.S. Department of Transportation’s Bureau of Transportation Statistics on the total number of scheduled flights, the number of canceled and delayed flights, and the average arrival delay length for delayed flights for major U.S. airlines. The data encompassed all flights operated by major mainline passenger airlines in November and December each year from 2021 to 2025.
We collected data on the number of bags handled and mishandled by airlines from the Air Travel Consumer Reports published monthly by the U.S. Department of Transportation. Mishandled luggage data was limited to November and December each year from 2021 to 2025.
To create the overall best and worst airlines for holiday travel score, we took the collected data points for each airline and compared them using a dynamic formula that assigned each airline a score of 0 to 5 relative to every other airline. We then weighted those scores to assign each airline a final value out of 50, with lower scores indicating airlines where holiday travel issues are more likely and higher scores indicating airlines that are more reliable during the holidays.
For each factor, a weight of 2.5 serves as the baseline, with weights above 2.5 having a larger impact on an airline’s total score and those below 2.5 having a lesser impact. Here are the weights for the individual metrics:
Percentage of Flights Delayed: 3
Percentage of Bags Lost or Damaged: 3
Average Delay Length (in minutes): 2
Percentage of Flights Canceled: 2
Data Notes
Spirit Airlines ceased operations on May 2, 2026, but it's included in our rankings because it operated during all five holiday seasons we analyzed.
Alaska Airlines and Hawaiian Airlines have operated under a single FAA operating certificate since October 2025. Because the Department of Transportation reports data for each carrier separately during the period analyzed, we list them as separate airlines.











